Celebrating cultural highlights of 1913...
Danny-blogging, essay 2 of 2
on the song "Danny Boy"
In celebration of the 100th anniversary of the
song “Danny Boy,” here’s a tasty selection of “Danny Boy” recordings by some
favorite artists. Please
understand: This list is purely
subjective as well as limited to songs that I can easily link to via YouTube. I’m making no claims that these are “the
best.” I’m simply making a claim
that: I like them!
So here are ten versions of Danny Boy, presented in chronological order, with a
bonus track at the end:
Judy Garland: I prefer this 1940 version to the
showier version that Garland
did in 1955, also available on YouTube.
With “Danny Boy,” I tend to prefer the simpler versions, no frills
needed.
Paul Robeson: With a restrained piano accompaniment,
Robeson’s sublime bass voice conveys great depths of meaning. Proof that men don’t have to be tenors to do
“Danny Boy” right!
Harry Belafonte: Taking his time, Belafonte’s mellow
timbre lingers in the air as the last note fades. Performed at Carnegie Hall, it sounds more
like he’s sharing the song privately one-on-one, perhaps comforting a loved one.
Mahalia Jackson: Usually associated with gospel music, Jackson ’s powerful voice
searches each word for new shades of meaning.
In her hands, “Danny Boy” sounds like it was meant to be a gospel song.
The Pogues: You don’t need to be pitch perfect to do a
classic “Danny Boy.” Shane MacGowan sounds like he’s lived it and that’s
what counts.
Frank Patterson: Of all these versions, this one sounds “most
right” to me—an Irish tenor pouring his heart out in song. Pretty cool that it featured so memorably in Miller’s Crossing (1990), too!
Judy Collins: Such a beautiful voice, singing a
capella. I love the absolute silence in
the hall until the waves of applause at the end.
Johnny Cash: This is from near the end of Cash’s
life, when he was making every word count.
Sinead O’Connor: I slightly prefer this live version to O’Connor’s
recorded one. On both, she includes a political
last stanza that was inserted anonymously many years ago and has become
something of a standard over time.
Celtic Woman: When angels sing “Danny Boy”…
And the 11th bonus track...
And the 11th bonus track...
Swedish Chef, Beaker, and Animal: “Moving right along, here are three gifted
singers who have all kissed the Blarney Stone…” It’s the Leprechaun Brothers!
Reference Sources
The Danny Boy Trivia Connection by Michael Robinson
© 2013 Lee Price
There's a different version by Celtic Woman (with Meav Ni Mhaolchatha being the main singer) that I think is even better than the one you presented. It's this one:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K2z4fiot8A8
Also, Deanna Durbin did a great rendition:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j32Fnb_8Bv4
And Jackie Evancho's version is excellent as well (sadly, her mother doesn't want her to ever sing the song again, calling it a "dirge"):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8s_jleJFR_M
Yes vote for Jackie. And only 10 years old at the time she recorded it.
DeleteI see these lists all over the place, and they all get it wrong. If you want to cry fir Danny boy, I've got one word for you: Meav
DeleteThanks for the list..You really should listen the version of Nana Mouskuri..
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JY6N2vEA6pI
ReplyDeleteDanny Boy is a favorite of mine. I listen to every version of it I can find.
Frank Patterson tops my list of renditions of Danny Boy by a male, and Celtic Woman had been at the top of my list for females. But I bumped them from the top spot in favor of a singer who has sang Danny Boy only once. That's correct, only once, she had never performed it, until the day this recording was made. Not only that she has not performed it since that day.
It was recorded as 1 of 19 songs to be considered for a then upcoming album. 14 of the 19 songs made it onto the album. 18 of the 19 made it onto the Deluxe Edition of the album. Danny Boy was the only song that did not make it onto that album, or any of her albums since then.
IMHO in the years to come this rendition of Danny Boy will be judged by future music scholars to be A Masterpiece for the Ages.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8s_jleJFR_M
Listen to and marvel at the beauty, emotional power, and vocal artistry of this singer.
And one more amazing fact, the singer was only 10 years old at the time she recorded this. Her name is Ms. Jacqueline Marie Evancho, her fans simple call her Jackie.
YES !!! Jackie Evancho has sung the best version of Danny Boy !!!!
Delete
ReplyDeleteDanny Boy is a favorite of mine. I listen to every version of it I can find.
Frank Patterson tops my list of renditions of Danny Boy by a male, and Celtic Woman had been at the top of my list for females. But I bumped them from the top spot in favor of a singer who has sang Danny Boy only once. That's correct, only once, she had never performed it, until the day this recording was made. Not only that she has not performed it since that day.
It was recorded as 1 of 19 songs to be considered for a then upcoming album. 14 of the 19 songs made it onto the album. 18 of the 19 made it onto the Deluxe Edition of the album. Danny Boy was the only song that did not make it onto that album, or any of her albums since then.
IMHO in the years to come this rendition of Danny Boy will be judged by future music scholars to be A Masterpiece for the Ages.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8s_jleJFR_M
Listen to and marvel at the beauty, emotional power, and vocal artistry of this singer.
And one more amazing fact, the singer was only 10 years old at the time she recorded this. Her name is Ms. Jacqueline Marie Evancho, her fans simple call her Jackie.
Jackie Evancho was only ten, the true prodigy. Perhaps when older on her own, she'll record Celtic Classics.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDoes anyone know what CD/DVD this version by Celtic Woman is on?
ReplyDeleteJackie Evancho's Danny Boy is way beyond any of these versions
ReplyDeleteDiana Krall on The Chieftains Tears of Stone cd always makes me tear up.
ReplyDeleteA version by an outstanding classic bariton, Thomas Quasthof:
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K95sZpg8Qu8
ReplyDeleteKeep the good work.
The Judy Collins link doesn't work. This one does. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SRjdrMAq5IE
ReplyDeleteMichael Litwin has them all beat. His video has vanished. Where did it go?
ReplyDeleteThe two versions of Danny Boy that for me stand out due to the feelings emitted are by Elvis and Eva Cassidy.
ReplyDelete